Dario Is Wrong: Yann LeCun Refutes Anthropic CEO's AI Job Apocalypse Prediction

Yann LeCun advises the public not to panic over AI job fears and to listen to economists instead of CEOs.

Topics

  • Image Credit- Krishna Prasad/ MIT Sloan Management Review Middle East

    Former Meta AI chief scientist and AI Godfather Yann LeCun has expressed views contrary to those of Anthropic CEO Dario Amodei following the latter’s remarks on AI reducing 50% of tech jobs.

    ​“Dario is wrong,” LeCun wrote on X, adding, “he knows absolutely nothing about the effects of technological revolutions on the labor market.” He also suggests that the public shouldn’t be alarmed by statements from AI leaders, such as Sam Altman, Yoshua Bengio, Geoffrey Hinton, or himself.

    ​Amodei, in an interview with Fox News, shared, “50% of all tech jobs, entry-level lawyers, consultants, and finance professionals will be completely wiped out within 1–5 years.”

    ​The Anthropic head has been sharing his views on the impact of jobs for a while now.

    When a user pointed out that LeCun was reacting to a six-month-old clip, he replied, “It’s still wrong, destructive, and dangerous.”

    ​Another user sided with Dario, citing a prediction by 1998 Nobel Prize-winning economist Paul Krugman, “By 2005 or so, it will become clear that the internet’s impact on the economy has been no greater than the fax machine’s.”

    ​LeCun contests that “one economist Nobel laureate was wrong once about one thing, therefore all economists are wrong” isn’t good logic.

    ​Another pointed out that AI differs from previous technologies in its capacity to replace human agency; hence, LeCun may be wrong.

    ​“The whole history of technological progress is one in which people became more productive and some professions were progressively displaced or eliminated. Yet this has never caused long-term mass unemployment. AI is just another technological revolution. People like Dario present it as qualitatively different from previous revolutions. It’s not,” he responded.

    ​LeCunn advises the public to listen to economists such as Philippe Aghion, Erik Brynjolfsson, Daron Acemoglu, Andrew McAfee, and David Autor, who “have spent their career studying this.”

    ​However, users were quick to point out that economists falter as well and may not be the best source of industry standards. “Listen to the economists.” They’re not paid to be right. None of the best investors pays any attention to them. As Warren Buffett said, “The best economist is the market,” said a user, while another wrote, “Dario probably had a lot of contacts across many industries. For sure, he sure knows some things.”

    For the AI Godfather, a tech CEO is as familiar with labor economics as “the head of a Formula 1 racing team knows about thermodynamics.” 

    ​With massive layoffs recently announced, he feels there are several reasons for them to do this. “AI is a good scapegoat. But uncertainties about international trade are likely a much bigger issue. Technological progress does cause temporary shifts in some jobs, but it never causes long-term mass unemployment.”

    Topics

    More Like This

    You must to post a comment.

    First time here? : Comment on articles and get access to many more articles.